• Be Sonnetary!

    Why buy flowers that fade?
    A sonnet lasts forever!
  • Brief Bio

    Lester Smith is a 2-term past president of the WFOP, a 4-time Origins-winning game designer, and a former JavaScript teacher for the HWG. He works days as a Writer/Technologist for the educational publishing house Sebranek Inc, nights and weekends as president of Popcorn Press.

  • Meta

  • Halloween Project

    Popcorn Press's 6th Halloween celebration is now on sale!

  • D6xD6 RPG

    Role-play in your favorite authors' worlds! Automatic 5% preorder discount.

  • Fencing Poker Deck

  • Other Card Games…

    Monster Con card game
    Invasion of the Saucer People card game
    Wolf Man's Curse card game
  • Suggested Reading

  • Undying Games

    Dark Conspiracy roleplaying game
    now by 3Hombres
    Dragon Dice game
    now by SFR Inc.
  • Cons I’m Attending

  • « | Home | »

    Why We Pick on the Weak

    By Lester | September 5, 2009

    Bullying is a fairly common topic in education nowadays. Frightened by the events at Columbine and such, many schools have set a zero-tolerance policy. The US Department of Health and Human Services has a Web site devoted to prevention of bullying. Experts from law enforcement and social work offer advice on how to deal with the problem.

    That’s all great. I support it enthusiastically.

    My purpose here, however, is to focus on “social bullying,” the threat of exclusion from a group, and ask, “What is it about human beings that leads them, within a social setting, to pick on the weak?”

    You know what I mean. It’s personified in Stephen King’s breakout novel, Carrie. It’s been treated in countless other novels and movies. It is, in effect, a trope, and that says something about its universality.

    The high school setting provides perhaps the most focused example. Nowhere else is such a cross-section of society gathered together in close proximity. Add walls, a ridiculously minute-conscious schedule, and an oppressive (if necessary) layer of adult authority, and voil? —human pressure cooker!

    In this vat, bullying reaches its apparent worst. I’d argue, however, that high school is really just a miniature of society overall—that its purpose is not merely to teach content knowledge, but also social context. By extension, I’d argue that the bullying in high school reflects a larger problem with social coercion in society overall.

    To put it another way, here’s my theory: There are two opposing forces acting upon every individual in a civilization. One is the force to excel, and that’s the one that gets the most direct attention, with awards given for competitions, financial rewards given for entrepreneurship, power given with political office, and so on. The other, less consciously recognized, is the force to fit in, to be part of the group (the herd), to not rock the boat.

    When an individual fails to fit in, whether by excelling or by falling short, the herd instinct is to bring pressure to bear. People who excel learn to do so despite that pressure, but they do suffer ostracism. People who fall short are equally ostracized, but they lack even the compensation of excellence.

    If we are honest with ourselves, we have to admit that even the kindest of us grow weary of weaklings. And by this, I don’t mean the disadvantaged. Virtually everyone respects the strength of a person who overcomes hardship. But until and unless that strength is evidenced, the instinct is to cut the person from the herd. It is simply a survival instinct: Keep up or die.

    I’m not trying to justify that instinct. Rather, it is my hope is that by becoming aware of it, we can civilize ourselves further. Instead of bullying the different into depression and eventual suicide (I point you to the “Ask the Experts” section of the aforementioned HRSA site), we can build a society in which they are better able to contribute. In the end, that is what civilization is really all about.

    Topics: Announcements | 6 Comments »

    6 Responses to “Why We Pick on the Weak”

    1. Ken St. Andre Says:
      September 5th, 2009 at 1:59 pm

      Why do bullies pick on the weak? Because the strong can fight back, that’s why!

    2. Lester Says:
      September 6th, 2009 at 11:13 pm

      Thanks for the comment, Ken. But that’s really not an answer, is it? For one thing, using the word “bullies” sidesteps the issue raised in the title, “Why WE pick on the weak.” I hope it’s clear in my essay that this is a whole-culture phenomenon, not just limited to bullies. Secondly, the question remains: Why does anyone pick on anyone? Focusing your answer just on choosing one target of two possibilities sidesteps that question as well.

      Ciao,

      Les

    3. Ken St. Andre Says:
      April 27th, 2010 at 4:57 pm

      Hmm, Les, since the body of your blog focussed so much on “bullying in educational environments”, I guess I overlooked the question of implicit guilt in the We in the title. I maintain that the answer is basically the same. Any aggressive action is founded on the idea of getting advantage with minimal expenditure of energy. Wolf packs cull the weak out of herds of deer because they can kill them more easily with less risk of damage to themselves. It’s the same in human society. Human wolves pick on the weak because the cost benefit ratio is better that way. On the other hand, there are some who practice aggression in order to get revenge. That’s what happens when the “weak” pick on the “strong”. Is revenge aggression fundamentally different from other forms of social aggression.

      Maybe the whole question of aggression comes down to human nature. We love to fight, and we continue to find new ways to do it.

    4. Lester Says:
      April 27th, 2010 at 11:05 pm

      Thanks for the clarification, Ken.

      However, characterizing some people as wolves and others as deer still seems too easy an answer. That’s the typical “us vs. them” picture.

      Maybe it’s that I’m trying to address a different question: Why does a group of people bully some members within that very group? This isn’t a wolves and deer topic, but rather a wolves culling their own pack or deer culling their own herd. I mention the school yard because that seems to be where this instinctive ostracizing of the weak and different first shows up, but it continues into adult situations like office politics.

      Frankly, I’ve grown distrustful and weary of characterizing some people as heroes and some as villains. That’s all well and good in fantasy fiction, but it doesn’t offer any progress to our civilization. And I do believe humans have progressed from warlike tribes to something more globally familial. If we’re going to survive, that civilizing process must continue. Wrestling questions like this, I suspect, is how we’ll get there.

    5. vishal Says:
      November 8th, 2010 at 8:45 pm

      Hi, Bully gurdian is picking on me.
      What should i do? They are kicking me out from their house, telling me and forcing me to live at places i do not want.

    6. Lester Says:
      November 8th, 2010 at 10:33 pm

      Hi, Vishal. Your comment doesn’t include enough info for a reasoned response. Do you mean “guardian”? If so, you ought to explain the situation to a counselor at school or church and ask for advice, or talk to someone at your local police department or courthouse.

    Comments